Picture a manufacturer whose supervisor wants to hire a temp she’s used for 400 hours. The temp earns $25.00 an hour and the agency bills $38.75, and when the supervisor asks about hiring him, the agency quotes a conversion fee of $10,400, which is 20 percent of his $52,000 salary. Nobody at the company knows whether that’s normal, whether it should have shrunk as the hours piled up, or what the markup already paid for. This scenario is invented for illustration and doesn’t describe a real company or agency.

This post explains the 3 charges that make up most staffing bills: the markup on temporary hours, the conversion fee when a temp becomes an employee, and the percentage a direct-hire placement costs. It leans on 3 public-sector contract documents that list real terms, a Kansas county’s request for proposals page, a Kelly Services exhibit and a TERRA Staffing Group exhibit, plus vendor guides and an Illinois Department of Labor notice, each attributed where it appears. Public-sector pricing may differ from private deals. All dollar examples are invented unless attributed. Confirm contract terms with counsel.

TL;DR

  • Markup is the multiplier on the pay rate, and it bundles several costs. Bill rate equals pay rate times 1 plus the markup. The Kelly exhibit says bill rates include payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, general liability and benefit packages. Markups in the public documents run from 28 to 42 percent in a Kansas county RFP, and a vendor guide cites 65 to 70 percent in a Robert Half contract. Ask what the number includes.
  • Conversion fees step down with hours, and the schedules differ widely. Kelly’s exhibit charges 25 percent of salary for the first 260 hours and 2.5 percent after 1,040. TERRA’s exhibit charges 15 percent through 200 hours and nothing after 520. In my invented 400-hour example, the same worker costs $2,600 to convert under TERRA’s schedule and $10,400 under Kelly’s. Read the clock, the salary base and the tail period.
  • Direct-hire fees usually run 20 to 30 percent of first-year pay, with a guarantee attached. Kelly’s exhibit says 25 percent, and TERRA says 20 percent below $75,000 and 25 percent above. Guarantees range from a 30-day replacement to a 90-day refund that steps down. A fee on an $80,000 salary swings from $16,000 to $24,000 across that range, so negotiate the percentage and the guarantee together.

Staffing fees at a glance

Staffing agencies earn money in a handful of ways, and a single placement can trigger several of them. The table collects the structures I found in public documents and vendor guides, with figures attributed to their sources. The Second Talent figures are secondhand, since that vendor says it took them from other contracts and agency terms, so treat them as leads. The public-sector documents list real terms but may not match private pricing. The right column tells you where each number comes from so you can check it.

FeeHow it’s chargedFigures reportedSource
Temp markupBill rate = pay rate × (1 + markup)28 and 42 percent in a Kansas county RFP; 65 percent administrative and 70 percent IT in a Robert Half contractSedgwick County page; Second Talent citing a Galveston agenda
Short assignmentsHigher markup for small jobsUp to 150 percent under 40 total hoursSecond Talent citing Reliable Staffing
OvertimeMultiple of the bill rate1.5 times the straight-time bill rateKelly exhibit
Temp-to-hire conversionPercent of salary that falls as hours buildKelly 25 to 2.5 percent; TERRA 15 to 0 percent by 520 hoursKelly and TERRA exhibits
Direct hirePercent of first-year pay20, 25 and 30 percentTERRA, Kelly, Second Talent
Retained searchShare of first-year cash payAbout a thirdSecond Talent citing Korn Ferry
PayrollingFee added to the worker’s hourly rate48 percentTERRA exhibit

How markup works

  • Start with the formula. The bill rate equals the pay rate times 1 plus the markup. Take an invented worker paid $20.00 an hour. At a 50 percent markup the agency bills $30.00, at 65 percent it bills $33.00 and at 70 percent it bills $34.00. A Second Talent worked example uses the same math. The markup is a percentage of the worker’s pay, which makes it larger than the agency’s margin on the bill.
  • Separate markup from margin. Markup divides the gross profit by the pay rate, while margin divides it by the bill rate. At a 50 percent markup on $20.00, the $10.00 difference is 33.3 percent of the $30.00 bill. At 65 percent, it’s 39.4 percent of the bill. Beancount.io’s guide makes the same point and tells agencies to build bill rates from a target margin. When an agency quotes either figure, ask which figure it means.
  • Know what the markup has to cover. The Kelly exhibit says bill rates include payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, general liability and benefit packages. The TERRA exhibit says the hourly rate covers wages, payroll burden and its service charge, and then adds a mandated-benefits surcharge on invoices. Those are different bundles, so a 40 percent markup from an agency isn’t comparable with a 40 percent markup from a rival unless the inclusions match.
  • Watch what sits outside the rate. The Kelly exhibit passes background and drug screening costs through at no added markup, and TERRA lists reference checks at $50 per candidate. Neither is part of the bill rate. A quote that looks cheaper per hour can cost more once screens, surcharges and timecard fees are added, so ask for every charge on a single page before you compare agencies. Keep the full list with the signed contract.

What the markup pays for

Most of the markup goes to costs the agency carries as the legal employer. Employer Social Security and Medicare tax come to 7.65 percent of wages, or $1.53 an hour on a $20.00 pay rate, a figure that Second Talent and beancount.io both use. Federal and state unemployment taxes, workers’ compensation and any benefits come on top. Beancount.io cites ranges for state unemployment and workers’ compensation without sources, and rates vary by state and job class, so ask the agency for its actual burden by role rather than relying on a general range.

The remainder covers recruiting, payroll administration, insurance, bad-debt risk and profit. The Sedgwick County RFP page lists markups of 42 percent and 28 percent for different vendors and positions, which shows how far apart public bids can sit even for similar work. The page also says its columns are scrambled in conversion, so I can’t match each figure to a vendor. The bigger point is that a lower markup may mean thinner service, a less expensive insurance policy or a narrower list of inclusions.

Gross margin data from company filings, as quoted by Second Talent, gives a sense of scale, with 39.0 percent for Robert Half contract in fiscal 2025, 22.8 percent for TrueBlue, 20.1 percent for Kelly and 16.7 percent for ManpowerGroup. These are company-wide figures that mix many clients and services, so they don’t tell you what any given contract earns. A margin of 20.1 percent equals about 25 percent of the agency’s own cost, which is a rough guide to how thin the cushion is.

Building a bill rate from the cost side

Start with the pay rate and the burden. Take an invented temp paid $25.00 an hour with a total burden of 12 percent, which is $3.00. The 12 percent is a placeholder, with 7.65 percent for Social Security and Medicare and the rest for unemployment tax and workers’ compensation. The agency’s cost is $28.00 an hour. Real burden varies by state and by job class, so use your agency’s actual figure.

Pick a target margin. At a 20 percent margin the bill rate is $28.00 divided by 0.80, or $35.00, a markup of 40 percent on pay. At 25 percent it’s $37.33, a markup of 49.3 percent. At 30 percent it’s $40.00, a markup of 60 percent. The agency earns $7.00, $9.33 and $12.00 an hour respectively. Beancount.io’s guide recommends this method, and its core formula checks out. Round the results for discussion only.

Compare with the quote. The invented agency bills $38.75, which is a 55 percent markup and implies a margin of about 27.7 percent on the bill after the $28.00 cost. That sits between the 25 and 30 percent cases. A buyer who sees the build-up can ask sensible questions, such as whether the burden figure is accurate or whether the margin target is higher than the market would bear. Check the arithmetic yourself before the meeting.

Use the build-up in negotiation. You can’t see the agency’s true cost, but you can test its logic. Ask which line items are in the burden, what the workers’ compensation rate is for the job class, and whether the markup changes at volume. Agencies often agree to a lower markup on large or long assignments. A request grounded in numbers gets a better response than a remark that says only that the rate seems high.

Overtime, short assignments and other add-ons

Overtime is where a bill can jump. Second Talent says Robert Half and Reliable Staffing bill overtime at 1.5 times the bill rate, with the markup included, and the Kelly exhibit says the same. On an invented $32.00 bill rate, an overtime hour costs $48.00. The TERRA exhibit says non-exempt overtime is billed at 1.5 times the employee’s regular hourly rate and only when the customer requests it, which could mean the pay rate or the bill rate. The exhibit doesn’t say, so ask.

Short assignments can cost more. Second Talent cites Reliable Staffing terms of up to a 150 percent markup for assignments under 40 total hours, a 4-hour charge when a worker is turned away, and a $100 fee per worker for late timecards, capped at $300 per invoice. It cites Robert Half terms of 1.5 percent a month on late payments, or the legal maximum if lower. These are a single vendor’s reading of other firms’ contracts, so check the actual agreement before assuming they apply to you.

Other add-ons come in contracts rather than in sales calls. TERRA’s exhibit lists a payrolling service fee of 48 percent added to the worker’s hourly rate, which suits a company that finds its own workers and wants an agency to handle payroll. Screening passes through at cost in the Kelly exhibit. Ask for a full schedule of fees before you sign, and ask which ones are negotiable. The most expensive surprises in staffing bills are usually small items that nobody read.

Conversion fees: the schedules in public contracts

  • Kelly Services. The Kelly exhibit for a California district charges a percentage of annualized salary that falls with hours on assignment, starting at 25 percent for 0 to 260 hours, then 20 percent for 261 to 520, 15 percent for the next band, 10 percent for 781 to 1,040 and 2.5 percent beyond 1,040. The 15 percent band is printed as 251 to 780, which looks like a typo for 521 to 780. A hire after 1,041 billable hours also requires payment within 21 days after the last hour worked.
  • TERRA Staffing Group. The TERRA exhibit charges 15 percent of starting salary through 200 hours, 10 percent from 201 through 360 and 5 percent from 361 through 520, and then nothing after 520 hours. The bands have a gap at hours 360 to 361 in the text. Temporary-to-hire conversions under that exhibit bill a 20 percent fee of estimated first-year earnings, with the remaining service charge invoiced at conversion. Ask the agency to confirm its bands in writing.
  • Robert Half OfficeTeam, per Second Talent. Second Talent says OfficeTeam charges 25 percent of annual starting salary, stepping down to 20 percent for hours 161 to 320, 15 percent for 321 to 480, 10 percent for 481 to 640 and nothing after 640 hours. That’s a secondhand description of a vendor’s terms, and I haven’t seen the source document, so treat the schedule as an illustration of a common design rather than as a quote.
  • Kansas county proposals. The Sedgwick County page lists many proposed schedules. They include 0 to 30 days at 25 percent, flat fees such as $6,000 for a nurse, hours-based bands from 33 percent down to 20 percent, and a waived fee from a single vendor. The text scrambled the columns, so I can’t tell which vendor offered which. The range, from nothing to a third of salary, is the finding. Ask the county for the original proposals.

An invented worker under 3 schedules

Take the invented temp who earns $25.00, billed at $38.75, so the agency collects $13.75 of markup over pay on each hour. His salary on conversion would be $52,000. The table applies 3 published schedules to his case at several hour counts: Kelly’s, TERRA’s and the OfficeTeam schedule Second Talent describes. The last 3 columns add the markup already paid to the conversion fee. The schedules come from different contracts, so the exercise shows how design drives cost and doesn’t predict any agency’s bill.

Hours workedMarkup paidKelly feeTERRA feeOfficeTeam feeMarkup plus KellyMarkup plus TERRAMarkup plus OfficeTeam
160$2,200$13,000$7,800$13,000$15,200$10,000$15,200
300$4,125$10,400$5,200$10,400$14,525$9,325$14,525
400$5,500$10,400$2,600$7,800$15,900$8,100$13,300
520$7,150$10,400$2,600$5,200$17,550$9,750$12,350
700$9,625$7,800$0$0$17,425$9,625$9,625

Hidden conversion terms to read

The clock. Agencies count hours in different ways. Second Talent says Reliable Staffing treats an assignment as temp-to-hire after 520 consecutive hours, which could reset the count if the worker takes a break. A consecutive count and an aggregate count can produce different fees for the same worker, so ask how breaks, holidays and gaps between assignments affect the total.

The salary base. Fees are usually a share of first-year pay, but the base can differ. The WorkGenius glossary page notes that a schedule may use base pay or total compensation, and TERRA’s exhibit uses starting salary for assignment conversions and estimated first-year earnings for temp-to-hire. If bonuses or overtime count, the same percentage costs more. Ask for the salary base in writing, and ask who decides the estimate when the final pay isn’t set at conversion.

Tails and violation fees. Contracts commonly protect the agency after a candidate is presented. The Kelly exhibit applies its direct-hire fee if the customer hires the candidate within 360 days of referral and reserves candidates for 12 months. TERRA bills direct hires that start within 12 months of presentation. Second Talent says Reliable Staffing charges a 10 percent violation fee if a client hires without telling the agency. Keep a log of every candidate an agency sends, and the dates.

Payment conditions. The Kelly exhibit grants its lowest fee of 2.5 percent only if the customer pays for the hours within 21 days after the last hour worked. That ties a fee discount to your accounts payable timing, so a late invoice could cost thousands. Ask whether any discount depends on payment speed, and put the invoice terms on the same checklist as the conversion terms so neither is forgotten.

Direct-hire percentages

  • The usual range. Second Talent says 20 percent is the most common direct-hire fee, citing a survey it attributes to SIA that put it at 42 percent of North American firms, and it names 25 percent for Robert Half in Houston-Galveston and 30 percent as the default for Robert Walters in New York. Its body text says 20 to 30 percent while a teaser says 20 to 35 percent. Those are vendor-reported numbers, so verify them against any quote.
  • Salary thresholds. The TERRA exhibit sets 20 percent of annual wages up to $75,000 and 25 percent at or above $75,000, billed on acceptance if employment starts within 12 months of presentation. A threshold creates a cliff: a $74,000 hire costs $14,800 and a $75,000 hire costs $18,750, a jump of $3,950 for a $1,000 difference in salary. Negotiate the base salary and the fee together if you’re near a threshold.
  • Flat fees. The Sedgwick County page lists direct-hire fees as flat amounts for some healthcare roles, such as $11,000 for a registered nurse, $8,000 for a licensed practical nurse and $5,000 for a nursing assistant, alongside percentage fees of 12 percent and 25 percent. Flat fees don’t track salary, so they help for high-paid roles and hurt for low-paid ones. Compare the flat figure with a percentage of your actual offer.
  • Retained search. Second Talent cites Korn Ferry for retained search at about a third of first-year cash pay. Retained searches are paid in stages whether or not the search succeeds, which is a different risk from contingency fees paid on hire. Executive and specialized roles often use retainers, while most staff hiring uses contingency. Ask what you receive if the search ends without a hire, and what stages trigger payment.

Direct-hire fees by salary

The table shows what common percentages cost at 3 invented salaries, plus TERRA’s threshold rule applied at each. Percentages of 15 and 33 percent aren’t from a single source. They bracket the range seen across the public documents and the retained-search figure that Second Talent cites. The last column applies TERRA’s threshold rule. Replace the salaries with your own offers and ask the agency to show the arithmetic before you accept a quote.

Salary15 percent20 percent25 percent30 percentAbout a thirdTERRA threshold rule
$60,000$9,000$12,000$15,000$18,000$20,000$12,000 (20 percent)
$80,000$12,000$16,000$20,000$24,000$26,667$20,000 (25 percent)
$120,000$18,000$24,000$30,000$36,000$40,000$30,000 (25 percent)

Guarantees and refunds

Guarantees decide what the fee buys. The TERRA exhibit gives a 90-day window for direct hires, with a choice between a replacement or a refund that falls with time, starting at 100 percent for days 1 to 29, 66.66 percent for days 30 to 59 and 33.33 percent for days 60 to 90. On an invented $10,400 fee, the refund would be $6,932.64 at the middle step and $3,466.32 at the last. Layoffs and reductions in force are excluded, a standard carve-out that deserves a careful read.

The Kelly exhibit is thinner. It offers replacement or a refund of a percentage of the fee if the hire ends within the first 30 calendar days, but only when the fee was paid within 21 days of the start date, and it doesn’t state the percentage. Second Talent reports a 90-day guarantee for Robert Half permanent placements and, for Robert Walters in New York, no refund but a replacement search if the hire leaves within 12 weeks. A refund and a replacement are different things, so ask which you get.

Read the exclusions and the conditions. Many guarantees apply only if the employee leaves or is terminated for cause, only if you pay on time and only once per hire. They may not cover a resignation caused by a change in duties or pay. A 30-day guarantee on a hire who takes 45 days to prove unsuitable is worth nothing, so match the window to how long it takes to see whether a hire works in your business.

State rules that change the math

Fee limits. An Illinois law firm blog says the Illinois Day and Temporary Labor Services Act limits the fees agencies can charge clients for converting temporary staff to permanent employees, and it doesn’t give the amounts or timing in the excerpt I read. An Illinois Department of Labor worker notice, as summarized by my fetch tool, says a fee can’t be charged by an agency after a laborer has performed work for 60 days, but I couldn’t see the surrounding text, so read the Act itself.

Equal pay. The same notice says a worker who performs work at the same client for more than 720 hours within a 12-month period has a right to equal pay. The worker must be paid at least the straight-time hourly rate of a directly hired employee entitled to overtime who does the same or substantially similar work. If no such employee exists, the floor is the rate of the lowest-paid directly hired employee entitled to overtime. That can raise the pay rate and, through the markup, the bill.

Everything else. I didn’t research other states, and several regulate temporary labor, so the fees in this post may be limited, disclosed in a particular way or taxed differently where you operate. Registration and insurance proof, for example, are part of the Illinois regime according to the law firm blog. Ask your agency in writing which state statutes govern its fees, and ask counsel to review the contract before you sign it.

Where published guides conflict

The Second Talent guide carries a byline date of October 15, 2026, while its page metadata shows a first publication of September 26, 2026. Its text cites a range of gross margins of 16.7 to 39.0 percent for listed firms but shows Robert Half permanent placement at 99.8 percent in its chart, outside that range. It gives direct-hire fees as 20 to 30 percent in the body and 20 to 35 percent in a teaser, and it compares a single 20 percent fee example with SHRM’s average cost per hire, which isn’t like-for-like.

Beancount.io’s staffing accounting guide has correct core formulas but says a $28 bid against a $24 cost would run at a single-digit margin, when the margin is 14.3 percent. It also writes the receivables formula in a way that gives $45 million rather than the $6.43 million its own example implies, because it multiplies days sales outstanding by weekly billings. The WorkGenius glossary page gives no percentages, hours or examples for conversion fees, so it can’t be verified. All 3 are commercial sources.

Public documents have their own flaws. The Kelly exhibit’s 15 percent band is printed as 251 to 780, its screening table is blank and its refund percentage is missing. The TERRA exhibit has a hole in its conversion bands at hours 360 to 361 and doesn’t list actual rates. The Sedgwick County page scrambled its columns, so I can’t map fees to vendors. Because of these gaps, I use all 3 documents to show structures and ranges, not as price lists.

Questions to ask before you sign

  • What’s in the markup? Ask for a list of what the bill rate covers: payroll taxes, unemployment tax, workers’ compensation at your job class rate, general liability, benefits and any administrative fee. Ask what’s billed separately, such as screening or a mandated-benefits surcharge, and whether the markup changes with volume or tenure. Get the answer in writing, because a bundle that looks complete on a sales call can leave out items that appear later on an invoice.
  • How is the conversion fee set? Ask for the schedule in hours, the salary base, whether hours are consecutive or aggregate and whether breaks reset the count. Ask what happens at the boundary hours, since the exhibits I read have typos and gaps at those points. Ask whether the fee is waived after a set number of hours or months and whether payment timing affects any discount. Put the answers in the contract itself.
  • What’s the tail? Ask how long the agency protects a candidate after presenting them or after a temp’s last day, and what the violation fee is. Ask how referrals are recorded and how you’ll be told. A tail of 12 months or 360 days can catch a hire you’d have made anyway, so keep your own log of every candidate and the source, and compare it with the agency’s records.
  • What’s the guarantee? Ask for the window in days, whether you get a replacement or a refund and what percentage is refunded at each step. Ask what excludes a claim, whether payment deadlines apply and whether the guarantee covers temp-to-hire conversions as well as direct hires. A guarantee that’s vague in a contract is a term the agency can interpret in its own favor when you need it. Get the terms in writing before you sign.

A negotiation checklist

Before you talk. Decide what you want: a temp, a trial or a direct hire. Estimate hours or salary and compute the fee under several schedules, using the table method above. Gather quotes from at least 3 agencies and ask each for the same itemized schedule, because comparing a markup to a bundle isn’t useful. Check whether state rules in your location limit conversion fees or require equal pay after a set number of hours.

In the talk. Negotiate the percentage, the hour bands, the tail and the guarantee together, since a concession on a single term can be paid for in another. Ask for the fee to step down faster, for a lower fee on long assignments and for a clear waiver point. Ask for the salary base to be base pay only. If the agency won’t move on the markup, ask about the conversion fee, and if it won’t move on that, ask about the guarantee.

After you sign. Keep a file with the contract, the rate sheets, the candidate log and every email that changes terms. Review invoices against the rate sheet each week for the first month. Calendar the conversion thresholds and the end of every tail, so a hire happens at the cheapest moment for you. Revisit the terms yearly, since agencies often adjust their rates in the contract’s pricing clauses, and ask counsel before you renew.

FAQs

What’s a typical staffing agency markup?

It varies by role, region and contract. A Kansas county RFP page lists markups of 42 percent and 28 percent for different positions, and Second Talent cites a Robert Half contract at 65 percent for administrative work and 70 percent for IT. The markup bundles payroll taxes, insurance and other costs, so compare what each quote includes. A single number, without its inclusions, tells you little about whether the price is fair.

What’s the difference between markup and margin?

Markup is the gross profit divided by the pay rate, and margin is the gross profit divided by the bill rate. At a $20.00 pay rate and a 50 percent markup, the bill rate is $30.00 and the $10.00 difference is a 33.3 percent margin. Ask which figure an agency quotes. Beancount.io recommends pricing from a target margin, which gives the agency a clearer view of what each hour must earn.

What’s a conversion fee?

It’s a single charge when you hire a temp or contractor directly, compensating the agency for the placement and the markup it loses, according to the WorkGenius glossary. Contracts usually set it as a percentage of salary that falls with hours worked. Kelly’s exhibit runs from 25 percent to 2.5 percent, and TERRA’s from 15 percent to nothing after 520 hours. Read the clock and the salary base. Always check the exact terms in your contract.

How much do direct-hire agencies charge?

Second Talent says 20 percent of first-year pay is the most common fee, with 25 and 30 percent in specific contracts. The Kelly exhibit uses 25 percent, and TERRA uses 20 percent below $75,000 and 25 percent at or above. On an $80,000 salary those percentages cost $16,000 to $24,000. Retained searches run higher at about a third of cash pay, per Second Talent citing Korn Ferry. Ask for the quote in writing.

Can I avoid a conversion fee?

Sometimes. Many schedules fall to nothing or a small administrative amount after a set number of hours, such as TERRA’s 520 hours or the 640 that Second Talent describes for OfficeTeam. You can also negotiate a waiver. Don’t try to avoid the fee by hiring around the agency during a tail period, because violation fees and tails can apply. Ask counsel to review the contract before any hire. Get any waiver in writing too.

What’s a replacement guarantee?

It’s the agency’s promise to find a replacement or refund part of the fee if a hire leaves soon after starting. TERRA’s exhibit gives 90 days with a refund that falls from 100 to 33.33 percent, while Kelly’s gives 30 days. Guarantees usually exclude layoffs and may require prompt payment. Ask whether you get a replacement or money back, and what voids the guarantee. Ask for the exact terms in writing before signing.

Are staffing fees negotiable?

Often. The documents I read show agencies quoting different schedules for the same kinds of work, and Kelly’s exhibit allows higher fees for hard-to-fill roles by separate written agreement, which implies the numbers move. Volume, assignment length and payment terms are common levers. Get quotes from several agencies, ask for itemized schedules and negotiate the markup, conversion fee, tail and guarantee as a package. Document every concession in the final contract language.

Do staffing fees include overtime?

Overtime is usually billed at a multiple of the bill rate. The Kelly exhibit says 1.5 times the straight-time bill rate, and Second Talent reports the same for Robert Half and Reliable Staffing. The TERRA exhibit says 1.5 times the employee’s regular hourly rate and doesn’t say whether that means the pay rate or the bill rate, so ask. An overtime hour costs far more than a straight-time hour. Confirm the multiplier before the first shift.

By

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *